top of page
sky test web back.png
Search

Spring Forward, Fall Apart: Why We're All Living in Permanent Jet Lag

Why Appalachian workers and students pay the steepest price for this national delusion 

 

There is a specific, haunting vibe to the Monday after Daylight Saving Time (DST). It feels less like a calendar event and more like a low-grade, collective hangover. It is a ritualistic act of self-harm where 330 million people simultaneously decide to sacrifice an hour of sleep to a policy that is over a century old, scientifically indefensible and, to put it mildly, really stupid. 


We treat DST like a quirk or bureaucratic annoyance. The data, however, reveals something darker: DST is a systemic policy failure that taxes our biology, economy and safety. It's a monument to obsolete thinking that costs billions and kills people. And right now, the Sunshine Protection Act—the worst possible outcome for everyone except corporations—is sitting in committees in Congress as we speak.


It is time to unite and stop Congress from treating the clock like a toy. 


Policy Born of Panic: Debunking the Energy Myth 


If you ask the average person why we do this, they will almost invariably tell you it’s for the farmers. This is the "George Washington chopped down the cherry tree" myth of timekeeping. Farmers actually hate Daylight Saving Time.


The true origin is far more cynical: it was a panic move during World War I. The German Empire implemented it first in 1916 to conserve coal for the war effort. The U.S. followed suit in 1918. The government kept the policy on life support for decades under the guise of "energy conservation." But the practice became irrelevant decades ago.  


The most damning evidence comes from the very people the policy is supposed to help. In 2008, the Department of Energy studied the massive extension of DST under the 2005 Energy Policy Act and found it reduced total primary energy consumption by 0.02%. That is not a saving; that is a rounding error. 


Even worse, independent research suggests that the policy wastes energy. In a 2008 study, economists Matthew Kotchen and Laura Grant found that DST increased residential electricity demand by 1%.  


ree

While people used slightly less light in the evening, they blasted their air conditioners during those "extra" sunny hours after work. That 1% increase costs Indiana households an estimated $9 million per year. We are disrupting our entire society to pay more for electricity. 


When the energy argument collapses, proponents pivot to the "shop ‘til you drop" defense—the idea that extended evening daylight stimulates commerce. However, real-world consumer spending data paints a much more complicated picture. 

A study by the JPMorgan Chase Institute, analyzing 380 million transactions, found that the end of DST results in a 3.5% drop in daily card spending per capita. Grocery stores take the biggest hit, seeing a nearly 6% decline. The "economic boost" is inconsistent at best and comes at a terrifying cost to our biology. 


The Body Horror 


The deepest objection to DST isn't political; it’s biological. 


Humans are running on fine-tuned hardware (our bodies) that relies on a specific daily software update (the sun). This is your circadian rhythm. When the government mandates DST, it forcibly shifts our "social clock" away from our "biological clock," creating a state of "social jet lag." 


Researchers describe social jet lag as the discrepancy between what our bodies need and what our schedules demand. Estimates show that under DST, the average person suffers a misalignment equivalent to flying from Paris to New York every Friday evening and back every Monday morning. 


The bill for this biological tax is steep. 

  • Heart Disease: Research suggests that every single hour of social jet lag increases the likelihood of heart disease by 11%. 

  • Obesity: The misalignment messes with ghrelin and leptin—the hormones that control hunger. One study found that for every hour of social jet lag, the risk of obesity rises by roughly 33%. 

  • Cancer: The World Health Organization has flagged circadian disruption as a probable carcinogen. 


DST is a state-mandated suppression of public health. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) is begging us to stop. They endorse Permanent Standard Time because it aligns with the sun.  


The Appalachian Penalty and the Coal Mine Canary 


While DST is annoying in New York City, it is outright dangerous in Appalachia. Geography plays a cruel trick here. The majority of Appalachia sits on the western edge of the Eastern Time Zone. 


Because of how the earth spins, the sun naturally rises and sets later in the Tri-Cities than it does in Boston, even on the same clock time. This is known as the "Western Edge Effect." Research shows that people living on the western edge of a time zone get, on average, 19 minutes less sleep per night than their eastern counterparts. This chronic sleep debt correlates with higher rates of obesity, diabetes, breast cancer and lower per capita income. 


The most chilling data comes from the mines. In a 2009 study, researchers Bares and Wagner analyzed 576,292 mining injuries reported to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health between 1983 and 2006. They focused on the Monday immediately following the springtime change. The results were terrifying: 

  • Injuries went up: There was a 5.7% increase in injury frequency compared to other days. 

  • Severity skyrocketed: The number of days of work lost due to those injuries—a proxy for how bad the injury was—jumped by a staggering 67.6%. 


DST-related fatigue impairs the critical cognitive functions needed to avoid catastrophic accidents. In a cubicle, a "tired mistake" is a typo. In a mine, it could spell disaster. 


The National Tab 


We often treat sleep as a luxury item. The economic reality is the exact opposite. Sleep is infrastructure. When that infrastructure crumbles, the economy collapses with it. 


In 2016, the RAND Corporation released a macroeconomic study that should terrify every CEO in America. They estimated that sleep deprivation costs the U.S. economy up to $411 billion a year. 


To put that number in perspective: 

  • That is 2.28% of the entire U.S. GDP. 

  • That is roughly the entire annual GDP of Ireland or Israel. 

  • That is more than the federal government spends on education, training and social services combined. 


We are hemorrhaging the wealth of a mid-sized nation every single year. 

The most staggering metric from the RAND study is the calculation of lost time. The U.S. loses roughly 1.2 million working days annually due to sleeplessness. Visualized, this is the equivalent of the entire working population of a city the size of Dallas simply vanishing from the workforce, every single day. 


Even worse, numerous studies confirm that DST has negative effects on students, particularly adolescents. Research shows that abrupt time changes result in sleep loss—averaging around 32 minutes per night—which leads to increased daytime sleepiness, slower reaction times and decreased vigilance. This sleep deprivation can impair cognitive functions, attention and mood. It has been linked to poorer academic performance and higher risks of accidents.  


The disruption of natural circadian rhythms disproportionately affects teenagers, exacerbating issues like mental health struggles, fatigue and decreased overall well-being. These effects persist for weeks after the change. 


The Russian Warning 


Right now, there is a movement in Congress to make DST permanent. Currently sitting in committee, this act sounds great on paper—"No more changing clocks!"—but it is the worst possible option.  


We know this because Russia tried it. 


ree

In 2011, Russia switched to permanent DST. The result was a disaster. Winter mornings became pitch black for dangerously long periods. Stress levels spiked. Health declined. Most critically, morning road accidents increased because commuters and schoolchildren were navigating icy roads in total darkness. 


It was so bad that the Russian government issued a rare apology and switched to Permanent Standard Time in 2014. If we pass the Sunshine Protection Act, we are voluntarily signing up for the same public health disaster. 


Breaking the Cycle 


We are trapped in a cycle of legislative abuse. We complain about the fatigue, we mourn the accidents, we pay the higher electric bills and then, six months later, we do it all again. We have accepted this biological tax as inevitable, but it isn't. It is a choice. 


The inertia keeping this system in place is political, not scientific. The danger right now is not just maintaining the status quo, but accidentally making it worse. The "Sunshine Protection Act" sounds like a warm, fuzzy piece of legislation, but it is a marketing trick paid for by powerful lobbying groups. It is a Trojan Horse for permanent jet lag that will force Appalachian children to wait for school buses in the dark and increase the risk of injury for every worker in the Mountain Empire. 


ree

Science is in and the debate is over. The only thing left to do is force the hand of the people holding the stopwatch. 


Let’s fix it once and for all. 


A Battle Plan for Appalachia 


If you are tired of the government gambling with your sleep, you need to make noise.  


1. The Message: When you call or email, you don’t need a fastidious essay. You need a clear demand that highlights our specific regional struggle. Use this script: 

"I am a constituent living in the Appalachian region, on the western edge of the Eastern Time Zone. I am asking you to OPPOSE the Sunshine Protection Act (Permanent Daylight Saving Time). 


Because of our geography, Permanent DST would force our communities to start the day in the dark for a significant portion of the year. This is dangerous for our students and our workers. I urge you to support Permanent Standard Time instead. Let’s stop shifting the clock and align our region with the sun." 


2. Who to Contact: Since this affects the whole mountain range, you need to find your specific representatives. 


3. Get Involved:  

 

 
 
 

Comments

SIGN UP AND STAY UPDATED!
bottom of page